You may have noticed that Gabe is wearing black gloves in the photo I posted a few days ago. In case you are curious, those are his batting gloves. Why does he have batting gloves, considering he is only three years old and doesn’t play baseball? That is a valid question, friends.
In the grand tradition of children everywhere, Gabe has batting gloves because his good buddy B started wearing batting gloves to school most days, and then Gabe was tortured by a deep, unrelenting need for batting gloves. He wasn’t tortured for long though, because pushover Mommy broke down and bought them pretty quickly.
The batting gloves have become an item of much controversy over the past week, though. Gabe hasn’t been sleeping well recently, and to my utter dismay, has returned to his pattern of waking up sometime between midnight and 2:00 a.m., wandering into our room, and randomly demanding something (he has to go potty, he’s thirsty and needs a drink, he can’t find his teddy bear, he needs mommy to come rest with him in his bed, he put two of his astronaut guys into his shoe and now he can’t find them, etc. The excuses are varied and plentiful.). Not only is this hard on me and Matt, it’s hard on Gabe. In the mornings following his late-night roamings, he is cranky, hot-tempered, and doesn’t eat well. His little body needs rest!
In an attempt to reverse this awful pattern, Matt and I tried a new strategy suggested by an important sounding but probably worthless child rearing book: if Gabe doesn’t sleep through the night, he is required to surrender one of his toys to us for the next day. He gets the toy back when he sleeps through the night again.
After a few days of this strategy completely and utterly failing, with Gabe roaming around our house in the pitch black like a miniature night stalker and then cheerfully handing over a toy the following morning, Matt pulled out the big guns: if Gabe didn’t sleep in his bed all night, he had to surrender the batting gloves. The BELOVED batting gloves.
This did not go over well, and Gabe tried bargaining with us, offering several different items instead: his talking Lightning McQueen, his light sabre, his Buzz Lightyear guy. “Nope,” said Matt firmly. “If you don’t sleep in your bed all night, you have to give us your batting gloves.” That was the final word on the matter.
Perhaps predictably, Gabe woke up around 2:00 a.m., and when we claimed the gloves the next morning, there was much crying and wailing and wringing of hands and gnashing of teeth. After a fairly wretched morning he went off to preschool forlornly, sad to face his friend B without his batting gloves. Matt and I didn’t like seeing him so sad, but we hoped he would start to understand that there are consequences for not staying in his bed all night, and that he needed to learn to rest his body. We quietly patted each other on the back for our skilled parenting.
Except when I picked him up from school that afternoon, he was wearing one batting glove on his hand! When he saw me from across the play yard a guilty smile crept over his face, and he tried to hide the gloved hand behind his back.
“Where did you get that?” I cried, pointing at the single glove. How did this excellent strategy backfire? I thought to myself. Surely Matt didn’t give in and let him have that!
“My friend B let me wear it since I forgot mine at home,” replied Gabe calmly, with the same guilty smile on his face. “I asked him if he would share his gloves with me and he said yes. So we each wore one of his today. I’ll give it back now,” he added. “Hey B, here’s your glove! Thanks for letting me use it!” Then he skipped off to get his backpack. And indeed, his teacher confirmed to me that Gabe talked B into handing over one glove early in the day.
This is one of those parenting moments where I sort of wanted to cry, really wanted to laugh, and had to force myself to keep it together so he wouldn’t see my reaction. Because, come on! My child totally outsmarted me and my husband and the parenting book and our brilliant plan! And he’s THREE! What on earth is he going to get away with when he’s TEN? Or SIXTEEN?

Gloveless in this picture, and still adorable.